OK, everybody look out. Where's my soapbox? Get the hell out of the way, because I'm climbing up on it.
THIS (http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=4959230n) was brought to my attention this morning and it's really got my panties in a bunch. What a bunch of nonsense. Here we've got Jeffrey Hollender, the President of Seventh Generation, a company that makes slightly-higher-quality-and-a-smidge-better-for-the-environment-than-you-find-at-Target disposable stuff (feminine hygiene products, toilet paper and other household paper products, and SURPRISE SURPRISE! disposable diapers), smugly telling us that, sometimes, disposables are actually BETTER for the environment than cloth. I just threw up a little in my mouth as I wrote that.
Here's the argument, and it's one I've heard before: the amount of water it takes to launder cloth diapers is the problem. In areas where there is little to no water available (he cites LA as an example), he claims disposables are a better choice; he does concede that in areas where water is plentiful, cloth wins.
Let's talk. Laundering cloth diapers at home typically uses 50-70 gallons of water every three days according to the 7th Gen. website. (http://www.seventhgeneration.com/big-green-lies/inside-poop-diapers). This figure is supplied as one of the reasons that 'sposies are better. Folks, if you flushed a regular flow toilet 5 times a day for 3 days, it's the same amount of water. Can we save a few flushes? Probably. Get a low flow toilet? Yep. Close the bathroom door so that Emma doesn't keep going in and flushing the toilet repeatedly because she likes the sound? Of course. (Oh wait, maybe that's just me.) Congratulations! You've just cancelled out the water use to launder your cloth diapers. Furthermore, the 50-70 gallons estimate is based upon data from a 1991 study, and those numbers could likely be significantly lower based on washes using today's high efficiency washing machines.
Bottom line: Single use (disposable diapers) DO consume less water than cloth diapers washed at home...BUT there are so many other environmental knocks against 'sposies that outweigh this (trees and other resources created to make them, ridiculous buildup in our landfills of something that likely will be there for another 500 years or so, questionable chemicals in the diapers, just to name a few). PLUS, cloth diapers laundered at a diaper service are known to consume LESS water than single uses. So, use a service, reap the benefits of cloth, and do it all without even having to wash them yourself. Awesome! The water usage controversy regarding cloth diapers has a long history, most of it fueled by companies like Seventh Generation (or Proctor and Gamble, the makers of Pampers), who have a vested interest in keeping people from cloth. You can read more about this at http://www.mothering.com/guest_editors/quiet_place/138.html. This is a really interesting article that reveals information about the so-called scientific studies (all funded by companies that sell disposables), including the one that was eventually discredited.
Of note also at the Seventh Gen. website is the claim that "Cloth diapers generally require the use of chlorine bleach for sanitizing purposes. Once rinsed down a drain, chlorine can combine with organic material naturally present in ground and surface waters to create toxins like chloroform." By and large, this is completely false. In fact, most cloth diaper manufacturers and retailers (of which I used to be one) advise that cloth diaper users NOT use chlorine bleach. Bleach tends to break down the fibers of the diaper, and therefore may effect their absorbency. In fact, an extremely popular and well-respected diaper manufacturer, Happy Heinys, says right on their website, "The use of chlorine bleach will...void all warranties and can lead to the breakdown of the waterproof layer of our fabric making the diaper unusable." Some diaper retailers or manufacturers might say to try it if you've exhausted every other possible solution for stains, and then rinse like crazy, but it is pretty much a no-no. (We pretty much all recommend bleaching them out in the sun...it works the best!) Yes, diapers need to be sanitized, and this is easily accomplished using a hot, hot wash. Turn up your water thermostat, or, if you don't want to do this, use a sanitizing agent in the wash such as Bac-Out. Bleach is not needed, nor is it recommended, as Seventh Generation indicates. It is of great interest to note that they neatly counter by telling us to purchase some sort of chlorine-free diaper, which (surprise again) they just happen to carry. Sorry, Jeff. Cloth diapers are chlorine free, too.
I think it is also worth mentioning that there is no reference to the added environmental boons that come when parents choose cloth diapers made from organic cotton, hemp, or bamboo. I'm sure that Seventh Gen. didn't bother mentioning these because it would put their products out of the green and into the environmental red by comparison.
How very sad that green is now just another controversial argument that companies use to sell more of their garbage.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

So, it was only the cloth diapers issue that got your panties in a bunch? Okay, I agree with you! But I'm afraid I'm only "talking the talk" because I've always used evil disposables. My theory before reading your column was this: a billion years in a landfill is worse that a little extra water & bleach. But to counteract my evil nature of disposables, I've switched the environmentally friendly "Diva Cup," to eliminate my "feminine" trash. That goes down as the STRANGEST thing I've done to help the environment! HA!
ReplyDeleteBTW, I was SO glad to see your new post! I've never read a more suspenseful writer! : )
ReplyDeleteIt is such a bummer; we in the cloth community have worked so hard to dispel the "water myth" and here this jerk goes and blows it all to sell more of his stuff. Ugh.
ReplyDeleteTrust me, I don't judge anyone for using disposables! They are far more convenient, and I know different folks make different kinds of efforts to "green" their lives. This just happens to be mine! ;) I am in the process of making that switch to the cup. But perhaps I will send you a private email so as not to subject the general public to this discussion...hahaha
Very well said, Steph. Thanks from one Greenie to another!
ReplyDelete