So I just had a chance to listen to a couple of songs that an old college friend recorded with his band. I sat here with my coffee and oatmeal, and just listened. Guitar, harmonica, and a voice that I knew to be purely HIS, unaltered by any sort of technology. It was nice. I know, I know, "nice" is the worst word a writer can use, but that's what it was. Peaceful, gorgeous, a relief from supersynthesized stuff I hear on the radio. (Shameless plug: check it out yourself at http://www.myspace.com/silvergirlsounds)
Okay, before I go too far, let me just say that I am not one of those militant music purists. My dirty confession is that I can rock out to "Oops, I Did It Again" with the best of them. But I don't really consider that MUSIC. It's something to bop along to as I drive or clean my house. It's high fructose corn syrup: very little substance, high on energy, good for short bursts, and with questionable origins. Everything has its place, even technology in music, but just not as a substitute for music. Music requires INSTRUMENTS, people. Steve played the freakin' harmonica in some of the songs, which is so cool. Think about a band like Dave Matthews and all the different instruments you might hear in some of their songs. Think about some of the other great bands over the years...when you go to the concert, they might not sound exactly the way they do on the radio. That's a good thing; it means you are being treated to a real organic music experience. Why go to the concert if you just want to hear the same exact cut you hear on the radio? What's the point? True talent of a band emerges in the unstructured jam session. Give me THAT at a concert. I can listen to (and enjoy, to an extent) enhanced fluff on the radio, but if I'm paying for a concert, give me MUSIC. Each has its place: it is the new classic archetype of the commercial vs. the profound. How sad that we can't more often find the two coinciding.
There's a larger issue at work here, far beyond music. How many things in our society can we look at under this lens? From television to Valentine's Day, the struggle between commercialism and depth rages. Watch Survivor, the reality TV juggernaut now highly suspected of being staged, or watch the History Channel or CNN for information and education. Give in to the hearts and flowers marketing and buy your Valentine a box of mediocre chocolates, a poorly made stuffed pink bear, and a dozen red roses that were marked up to three times their regular price, or just make a nice dinner and write a heartfelt card or poem for that special someone. Can't there be some middle ground? Can't we find some depth in our obsession with "reality" TV? Maybe, maybe not.
As in all things, I am once again reminded of the old adage about moderation. Technology, television, chocolates, even profundity itself. All of these things are good in medium-sized doses. Maybe a little more on a rainy day. Find the thing you love, that you can't get enough of, that makes you the best of who you are, and feel free to OD on it, but everything else...pick out the best parts, and leave it at that.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Good ol' Spears. ; ) Takes us back to our SHA days, doesn't it. And, hey, you won't believe this, . . . one of my best friends is married to Gabe from "Survior: Marquesas"!!! (And I was friends with her three years before I found that out!!!)
ReplyDelete